World Beverage Institute
Wine

Italian Wine Sector Urged to Abandon Burgundy Comparisons in Favor of Native Identity

Published 10 November 2026 · WBI Industry News
Italian Wine Sector Urged to Abandon Burgundy Comparisons in Favor of Native Identity
Image: Decanter

Industry experts and commentators are encouraging Italian winemakers to stop relying on Burgundy as a benchmark, warning that marketing native wines through French comparisons undermines Italy's distinct regional identities and native grape varieties.

Italian winemakers and trade professionals are facing calls to cease comparing native Italian wines and regions to Burgundy, with industry commentators arguing that the habit risks diluting Italy's distinct market identity and undercutting the commercial value of its indigenous grape varieties. Writing for Decanter, international wine writer and educator Michaela Morris highlights a persistent industry practice of describing Italian wines as 'Burgundian,' asserting that such analogies obscure the unique characteristics of Italian viticulture in pursuit of external validation.

While Burgundy has influenced global winemaking practices—particularly regarding the segmentation of appellations into smaller geographical units, as seen in Barolo, Barbaresco, Soave, Chianti Classico, and Etna—industry figures warn against stylistic imitation. Decanter World Wine Awards Co-Chair Michael Hill Smith MW emphasized the distinction between seeking inspiration and attempting emulation. Similarly, while producer and importer Marco de Grazia famously dubbed Etna 'the Burgundy of the Mediterranean' to help the once-obscure region gain international traction, local winemakers like Alberto Graci stress that the primary objective should be producing wines with distinct personalities rather than copying foreign styles.

The commercial and philosophical implications of this trend are receiving increased scrutiny across the trade. In his book Italianity (co-authored with Jessica Dupuy and published by Greenleaf in June 2026 for US$50), Master of Wine Andrea Lonardi writes that Italy has historically searched for validation in external standards. Lonardi cautions that winemakers risk sacrificing authentic regional identity when pursuing French winemaking ideals.

Morris argues that comparing varieties such as Sangiovese, Nebbiolo, Nerello Mascalese, Corvina, Frappato, Pelaverga Piccolo, and Rossese to Pinot Noir sets up misleading consumer expectations. Furthermore, with Burgundy pricing reaching historically high levels, positioning Italian wines relative to inaccessible French benchmarks is increasingly viewed as counterproductive. Instead, industry analysts suggest that Italy's commercial strength lies in showcasing its broad spectrum of indigenous flavor profiles—such as the power of Sagrantino, the richness of Primitivo, or the character of local grapes like Lazio's Cesanese d'Affile—which offer distinct personality, food-friendly acidity, and accessible price points.

Key facts

  • Wine writer Michaela Morris calls for an end to describing Italian wines and regions as 'Burgundian' in Decanter.
  • Decanter World Wine Awards Co-Chair Michael Hill Smith MW stresses the difference between inspiration and emulation in winemaking.
  • Italian appellations including Barolo, Barbaresco, Soave, Chianti Classico, and Etna have adopted smaller geographical units inspired by Burgundy's focus on origin.
  • Marco de Grazia previously dubbed Etna 'the Burgundy of the Mediterranean' to build international market awareness.
  • Andrea Lonardi MW and Jessica Dupuy released the book Italianity (Greenleaf, June 2026, US$50), arguing that Italian winemakers must not sacrifice identity for French ideals.
  • Damiano Ciolli's Silene, Olevano Romano 2024 (made from Cesanese d'Affile) retails between £22 and £24 through UK distributors.

Why it matters

The debate over wine positioning highlights a strategic shift in international wine marketing. By moving away from French benchmarks like Burgundy, Italian producers can better protect and commercialize their unique native varieties, establish distinct regional brand equity, and manage consumer expectations in premium export markets.

Italian Wine Burgundy Wine Marketing Native Varieties Viticulture Brand Positioning

Sources
  • Decanter — 2026-11-09: “It's time Italy stopped comparing its wines to Burgundy – Michaela Morris”

This article was prepared by WBI.org from the sources listed above with the assistance of AI and reviewed by a WBI editor before publication. Information is attributed to its original sources.

All industry news